ICN Kick-Off Call 2024

ICN “Kick-Off Call”
Hear from the ICN Working Groups on New Work Products and
How to Get Involved in this Year’s Projects
Wednesday, September 18, 2024
08:00–09:00 (Ottawa)/14:00–15:00 (Bonn)
ICN working groups and project teams will present new work products, work plans for 2024/2025, ICN events, and opportunities to participate in this year’s projects.
ICN Cartel Workshop 2024

The workshop was hosted by the Mexican Federal Economic Competition Commission (Cofece) from 2-4 October 2024 in Mexico City at the Barceló Reforma México Hotel.
This year’s event, entitled The Future of the Fight Against Cartel Agreements explored the challenges that competition agencies are facing and will face in the near future regarding the detection, investigation and enforcement of the law against cartels. The workshop featured both technical and practical sessions covering topics ranging from proactive detection tools, the impact of new technologies on collusion and the future of international cooperation in cartel enforcement.
The press release is available here.
ICN Merger Workshop

ICN 2024 MERGER WORKSHOP
13-15 November 2024
TAIPEI, TAIWAN
The International Competition Network (ICN) Merger Workshop was held by the Taiwan Fair Trade Commission at the Regent Hotel in Taipei, Taiwan, from 13 to 15 November 2024.
The two-and-a-half-day workshop offered opportunities for national competition authorities (NCAs) and non-governmental advisors (NGAs) to discuss and exchange experiences on highly topical merger issues, including potential/dynamic competition, innovation theories of harm in both horizontal and non-horizontal mergers as well as other non-price parameters of competition. Given the increasingly dynamic nature of competition enforcement in digital and other sectors, these topics are more pertinent than ever.
Participants had the opportunity to discuss in an interactive setting various hypothetical cases (e.g. theories of harm, remedies, investigative tools), to elaborate on draft Merger Working Group products and discuss, among other topics, procedural aspects of merger investigations.
More information and videos are available here.
ICN in brief 2024/25
Check the 2024/25 ICN projects and get involved.
More detailed information and additional projects can be found in the ICN Working Group work plans available on the Working Group subpages along with the relevant contact information.
ICN Sustainability Workshop
Join Us for the ICN Workshop on Competition and Sustainable Development
We are excited to announce the first ICN workshop on “The Role of Competition in Supporting Sustainable Development Goals,” which will be organized by the French Autorité de la concurrence and held online from July 2-3, 2024.
Event Overview
This workshop will explore the crucial role that competition plays in achieving sustainable development goals. It will provide a platform for experts, heads of agencies, and non-governmental advisors (NGAs) to discuss and share insights on integrating sustainability considerations into competition law assessments.
Agenda Highlights
Day One accessible here: Open to ICN Members
1:00 pm CEST: Introductory remarks by President Benoît Coeuré
1:15 pm – 2:15 pm CEST: Panel Discussion 1: “Sustainability considerations in competition law assessments: competition agencies’ mandate and where to draw the line.” This session will feature a moderator and four speakers who will delve into the mandates of competition agencies and the boundaries of sustainability considerations in legal assessments.
2:15 pm – 3:15 pm CEST: Panel Discussion 2: “How to effectively address behaviors that positively or negatively affect sustainability: advocacy, ex ante guidance, and the suitability of traditional enforcement tools.” This panel will discuss the practical tools and strategies for addressing sustainability-related behaviors.
3:15 pm – 3:30 pm CEST: Closing remarks by ICN Chair Andreas Mundt
Day Two: Agencies Only
This day will be dedicated to internal discussions among agency experts, focusing on practical issues and challenges related to sustainability in their day-to-day work. Topics will include capacity building, advocacy, ex ante guidance, and enforcement.
If you have any questions regarding the event or your agency is willing to share relevant experience on these topics, please feel free to contact us at [email protected]
We look forward to your participation in this event as we explore the intersection of competition and sustainability to support global development goals.

ICN Steering Group confirms Andrea Marván, COFECE Mexico, as new ICN Vice Chair
ICN Steering Group confirms Andrea Marván, COFECE Mexico, as new ICN Vice Chair

Andrea Marván Saltiel, Chair of the Mexican Federal Economic Competition Commission (COFECE), has been newly appointed as one of two ICN Steering Group Vice Chairs at the ICN Annual Conference in Brazil in May 2024 alongside Lina Khan, Chair of the US FTC. In this capacity, Andrea will focus on emerging competition issues.
The ICN would like to thank Sia Aik Kor for her commitment and leadership as former ICN Vice Chair.
Comment les codes bonus casino ont évolué en France selon Casinara
L’histoire des codes bonus dans les casinos en ligne français est indissociable de l’évolution réglementaire du secteur. Pendant longtemps, les opérateurs offshore proposaient des offres promotionnelles sans aucun cadre légal, laissant les joueurs dans une zone grise juridique. Depuis l’ouverture partielle du marché en 2010, les pratiques commerciales des casinos ont considérablement changé, et les codes bonus en particulier ont suivi une trajectoire propre, façonnée par les contraintes légales, les attentes des joueurs et les stratégies des plateformes. Comprendre cette évolution permet de mieux saisir pourquoi les offres disponibles aujourd’hui sont si différentes de celles qui circulaient il y a une décennie.
L’avant-2010 : une époque de promotions sans frontières
Avant la loi du 12 mai 2010, dite loi Hortefeux, qui a ouvert et régulé le marché des jeux en ligne en France, les casinos opéraient principalement depuis des juridictions comme Malte, Gibraltar ou les Antilles. Dans ce contexte, les codes bonus étaient des outils marketing extrêmement agressifs. Un joueur français pouvait entrer un code promotionnel pour obtenir un bonus de bienvenue pouvant atteindre 200 % à 400 % du dépôt initial, parfois sans conditions de mise clairement définies.
Ces pratiques étaient courantes parce qu’aucune autorité française ne pouvait les encadrer. Les opérateurs rivalisaient d’inventivité : codes bonus pour les anniversaires, pour les rechargements hebdomadaires, pour le parrainage d’amis, ou encore des codes distribués via des forums spécialisés. Le joueur collectionnait ces codes comme des coupons de réduction, en profitant d’un marché non régulé où la concurrence était féroce. En l’absence de régulation nationale, certains opérateurs utilisaient ces bonus comme des instruments de rétention parfois trompeurs, avec des exigences de mise dissimulées dans des conditions générales rédigées en anglais ou dans une langue étrangère.
La régulation de 2010 et ses effets immédiats sur les promotions
La création de l’Autorité de Régulation des Jeux En Ligne (ARJEL) en 2010 a marqué un tournant décisif. L’ARJEL, devenue ANJ (Autorité Nationale des Jeux) en 2020 après la fusion avec la Française des Jeux et le PMU, a imposé des standards de transparence inédits. Les opérateurs agréés ont été contraints de présenter leurs offres promotionnelles de manière claire, avec des conditions de mise explicites, des durées de validité précises et des plafonds de gains liés aux bonus.
Concrètement, les codes bonus ont commencé à perdre de leur caractère “magique” pour devenir des instruments commerciaux normalisés. Les montants ont été revus à la baisse : là où un code pouvait autrefois débloquer 500 euros de bonus, les offres post-régulation se limitaient souvent à 100 ou 150 euros, assortis de conditions de mise de 20 à 35 fois le montant du bonus. Ce recadrage a certes protégé les joueurs contre certaines pratiques abusives, mais il a également rendu le marché français moins attractif que les marchés offshore aux yeux de certains joueurs expérimentés.
Il faut noter que l’ARJEL n’a jamais interdit les codes bonus en tant que tels, mais elle a exigé que tout avantage promotionnel soit mentionné dans les conditions générales déposées auprès de l’autorité. Cette obligation de dépôt préalable a ralenti la capacité des opérateurs à lancer des promotions flash ou des codes temporaires, ce qui a modifié profondément la dynamique du secteur.
L’évolution des formats entre 2015 et 2023
La période 2015-2023 a été marquée par une sophistication croissante des mécaniques de bonus. Les codes simples de type “BONUS100” ont progressivement laissé place à des systèmes plus complexes : codes liés à des événements sportifs, codes réservés aux membres d’un programme de fidélité, ou encore codes générés dynamiquement pour chaque joueur selon son historique de jeu. Cette personnalisation, rendue possible par les avancées en matière d’analyse de données, a transformé le code bonus d’un outil générique en un levier de fidélisation ciblé.
Des plateformes spécialisées dans la comparaison des offres ont émergé durant cette période pour aider les joueurs à s’y retrouver dans la multitude de promotions disponibles. C’est dans ce contexte que des ressources comme http://casinara.com/codes-bonus-casino/ ont pris de l’importance, en centralisant les informations sur les codes actifs et en expliquant les conditions associées à chaque offre, ce qui représentait un véritable service éditorial pour les joueurs cherchant à comparer les promotions disponibles sur différentes plateformes.
Sur le plan réglementaire, l’ANJ a également renforcé les exigences en matière de jeu responsable à partir de 2020. Désormais, les opérateurs doivent s’assurer que les codes bonus ne sont pas proposés à des joueurs ayant activé des outils d’auto-exclusion ou des limites de dépôt. Cette contrainte technique a nécessité des investissements importants dans les systèmes de gestion des promotions, et certains petits opérateurs ont renoncé aux codes bonus pour cette raison.
Parallèlement, le marché a vu apparaître des codes bonus sans dépôt, dits “no deposit”. Ces codes permettent d’obtenir un crédit de jeu ou des tours gratuits sans effectuer de versement préalable. Bien que leur valeur soit généralement faible — entre 5 et 20 euros — ils ont connu un succès notable car ils permettent aux nouveaux joueurs de tester une plateforme sans risque financier immédiat. Selon les données publiées par l’ANJ dans son rapport annuel 2022, le nombre de nouveaux comptes ouverts sur des plateformes agréées a augmenté de 18 % entre 2019 et 2022, une tendance que certains analystes attribuent en partie à la démocratisation de ces offres d’essai sans dépôt.
Les tendances actuelles et les défis réglementaires à venir
Aujourd’hui, les codes bonus dans les casinos en ligne accessibles depuis la France se déclinent en plusieurs catégories bien distinctes. On distingue les codes de bienvenue pour les nouveaux inscrits, les codes de rechargement pour les joueurs existants, les codes liés à des événements spécifiques comme les tournois ou les jackpots progressifs, et enfin les codes exclusifs distribués via des partenaires éditoriaux ou des affiliés agréés. Chaque catégorie obéit à des règles différentes en termes de conditions de mise et d’éligibilité.
L’un des défis majeurs pour les opérateurs agréés en France reste la concurrence des sites non licenciés. Malgré les efforts de l’ANJ pour bloquer l’accès à ces plateformes — plus de 500 sites ont été bloqués entre 2010 et 2023 — les joueurs techniquement avertis continuent d’accéder à des offres offshore via des VPN. Ces sites proposent des codes bonus sans les contraintes réglementaires françaises, ce qui crée une distorsion de concurrence difficile à résoudre sans une harmonisation européenne plus poussée.
La question de la publicité pour les codes bonus est également au cœur des débats actuels. Depuis 2021, l’ANJ a durci ses positions sur la publicité ciblant les jeunes adultes et les personnes vulnérables. Les opérateurs doivent désormais obtenir une validation préalable de leurs campagnes promotionnelles incluant des codes bonus avant de les diffuser sur les réseaux sociaux ou les plateformes de streaming. Cette mesure a eu pour effet de réduire la visibilité de certaines offres, mais elle a aussi poussé les opérateurs à investir davantage dans des canaux éditoriaux plus qualitatifs, comme les sites de comparaison ou les guides spécialisés.
Du côté technologique, l’intégration des codes bonus dans les applications mobiles a modifié les usages. En 2023, plus de 60 % des sessions de jeu en ligne en France se déroulent sur smartphone selon les estimations sectorielles. Les codes sont désormais souvent remplacés par des liens de promotion activés automatiquement lors de l’inscription via une application, ce qui rend la notion même de “code” de plus en plus abstraite pour les joueurs. Certains opérateurs ont abandonné le système de codes alphanumériques au profit de boutons d’activation intégrés directement dans l’interface, simplifiant l’expérience utilisateur mais réduisant la dimension “chasse au trésor” qui faisait partie du charme originel des codes bonus.
L’évolution des codes bonus casino en France reflète en définitive une maturation progressive du marché. Partis d’un environnement non régulé où tout était permis, ces outils promotionnels ont été progressivement encadrés, normalisés, puis sophistiqués pour s’adapter aux exigences légales et aux attentes d’une clientèle plus informée. Si la régulation a parfois été perçue comme un frein à l’innovation commerciale, elle a surtout contribué à assainir un secteur qui en avait besoin, en plaçant la transparence et la protection du joueur au centre des pratiques promotionnelles. Les prochaines années, marquées par l’essor de l’intelligence artificielle et la personnalisation poussée des offres, promettent une nouvelle transformation de ces mécaniques, dans un cadre réglementaire qui devra lui aussi s’adapter en conséquence.
2024 ICN Annual Conference in Sauipe, Brazil
The 23rd Annual Conference of the International Competition Network (ICN) was hosted by the Brazilian Administrative Council for Economic Defense (CADE) in Sauipe, Brazil from 14 to 17 May 2024.
At the conference, participants shared experiences and engaged in discussions in the plenaries and breakout sessions organised by the ICN working groups. Special sessions were dedicated to new developments in the field of artificial intelligence as well as the topic of state-owned enterprises for which the ICN had also invited the OECD and UNCTAD to participate.
For further information on the ICN Annual Conference, please visit the conference website (https://icn2024sauipe.cade.gov.br/). The recordings of the plenary sessions are available here without prior registration.
The ICN Statement of Achievement 2023-2024 is available here.
How Betzoid Covers the Fundamentals of Football Betting Strategies
Football betting has evolved from informal wagers placed between friends on match days into a sophisticated, data-driven industry worth hundreds of billions of dollars annually. As the global appetite for sports betting has grown, so too has the demand for platforms that help bettors move beyond guesswork and develop structured, informed approaches to wagering. Betzoid has emerged as one of the more comprehensive resources in this space, offering bettors a layered educational framework that addresses everything from basic market terminology to advanced analytical methodologies. Understanding how Betzoid approaches this educational mission reveals a great deal about what separates disciplined, strategic betting from impulsive gambling behavior.
The Foundation of Football Betting Knowledge: Markets, Odds, and Value
Before any strategy can be meaningfully discussed, a bettor must possess a firm grasp of the foundational concepts that govern football betting markets. Betzoid dedicates considerable attention to this groundwork, recognizing that many bettors enter the market without fully understanding how odds are constructed, what they represent probabilistically, or how bookmakers build their margins into pricing structures. This foundational ignorance is, statistically speaking, one of the primary reasons recreational bettors consistently lose money over time.
Odds formats vary significantly across different regions and platforms. Decimal odds, which are predominant in Europe and Australia, express the total return per unit staked, including the original stake. Fractional odds, historically favored in the United Kingdom and Ireland, express profit relative to the stake. American moneyline odds, expressed as positive or negative integers, indicate how much profit a successful $100 bet would yield or how much must be staked to win $100. Betzoid’s educational content walks readers through each format systematically, ensuring that bettors can convert between systems fluently and interpret odds accurately regardless of the platform they use.
Perhaps more importantly, Betzoid emphasizes the concept of implied probability — the likelihood of an outcome as suggested by the odds offered. A decimal odd of 2.50, for example, implies a 40% probability of that outcome occurring. When a bookmaker applies a margin, the sum of implied probabilities across all possible outcomes in a market exceeds 100%, representing the house edge. Understanding this overround is essential for any bettor attempting to identify value. Betzoid frames value betting not as a guarantee of short-term profit but as a long-term strategy of consistently identifying situations where the true probability of an outcome exceeds the implied probability embedded in the odds.
The platform also addresses the historical development of football betting markets. In the early days of organized football wagering in England during the late 19th and early 20th centuries, betting was largely confined to match result markets — win, draw, or loss. The expansion of betting exchanges in the early 2000s, pioneered by platforms like Betfair, fundamentally transformed the landscape by allowing bettors to act as both punter and bookmaker, laying outcomes as well as backing them. This shift democratized access to sharper pricing and introduced concepts like lay betting into mainstream discourse, all of which Betzoid contextualizes within its strategic content.
Core Betting Strategies: From Single Markets to Systems Thinking
With foundational knowledge established, Betzoid moves into the practical territory of betting strategies, presenting a range of approaches suited to different risk tolerances, bankroll sizes, and analytical capabilities. The platform avoids the trap of presenting any single strategy as universally superior, instead framing each approach within the context of specific conditions under which it tends to perform well or poorly.
The match result market — commonly referred to as the 1X2 market — remains the most widely wagered football market globally. Betzoid explains how experienced bettors analyze this market not simply by predicting winners but by assessing whether bookmaker odds accurately reflect team form, injury news, historical head-to-head records, and contextual factors such as fixture congestion or motivational dynamics late in a season. For instance, a team mathematically safe from relegation and already eliminated from European contention may field a weakened squad in a final league fixture, creating a market inefficiency that sharp bettors can exploit.
Asian handicap betting represents one of the more nuanced markets that Betzoid covers in detail. Originating in Asia during the 1990s and subsequently adopted globally, Asian handicap markets eliminate the draw outcome by assigning a goal advantage or deficit to each team, creating a two-way market with generally sharper pricing than traditional 1X2 markets. Quarter-ball and half-ball handicaps introduce additional complexity that Betzoid unpacks methodically, making these markets accessible to bettors who might otherwise avoid them due to their apparent complexity.
Over/under goal markets, both at the full-match level and for individual halves, offer another avenue for strategic betting. Betzoid highlights how factors such as team tactical setups, referee tendencies, weather conditions, and match importance all influence expected goal totals in ways that bookmakers do not always price with complete accuracy. Bettors who develop expertise in a specific league or competition can accumulate informational advantages over generalist bookmakers covering dozens of markets simultaneously. For those looking to deepen their understanding of such approaches, well-structured football betting tips can serve as a practical bridge between theoretical strategy and real-world application, providing context-specific analysis grounded in current form and statistical modeling.
Betzoid also addresses accumulator betting — the practice of combining multiple selections into a single bet where all selections must win for the bet to pay out — with appropriate nuance. While accumulators offer the appeal of transforming small stakes into large returns, Betzoid is careful to explain the mathematical reality that each additional selection multiplies the bookmaker’s margin, making accumulators statistically disadvantageous over large sample sizes. The platform does not dismiss accumulators entirely but contextualizes them as entertainment products rather than vehicles for systematic profit generation.
Staking strategies receive substantial coverage as well. The Kelly Criterion, developed by mathematician John Kelly in 1956 and subsequently adopted by professional gamblers and investors alike, provides a mathematical framework for determining optimal bet size based on perceived edge and available bankroll. Betzoid explains both the full Kelly approach and fractional Kelly variants, acknowledging that the full Kelly formula, while mathematically optimal under certain assumptions, can produce dramatic bankroll swings that many bettors find psychologically difficult to manage.
Data Analytics and the Modern Approach to Football Betting Research
The proliferation of advanced football statistics over the past decade has fundamentally altered how serious bettors approach research and analysis. Metrics such as expected goals (xG), expected assists (xA), shot quality data, and pressing intensity statistics have moved from the domain of academic sports science into mainstream betting discourse. Betzoid engages with this analytical revolution thoughtfully, helping bettors understand not only what these metrics measure but also their limitations and appropriate applications within a betting context.
Expected goals, perhaps the most widely discussed advanced metric in football analytics, attempts to quantify the quality of scoring chances based on historical shot data. A team that consistently generates high-xG values but scores fewer actual goals than expected may be experiencing finishing variance that is likely to normalize over time — a situation that can create betting value if bookmakers continue to price that team based on their actual goal record rather than their underlying performance quality. Betzoid illustrates these concepts with practical examples, making abstract statistical principles tangible and applicable.
The platform also addresses the importance of league-specific research. Football betting markets differ substantially in efficiency depending on the competition. Top European leagues such as the English Premier League, Spanish La Liga, German Bundesliga, and Italian Serie A are covered extensively by bookmakers and betting syndicates, meaning market inefficiencies are identified and corrected rapidly. Lower-division leagues, particularly in smaller footballing nations, may offer more persistent inefficiencies for bettors willing to invest the time in specialized research. Betzoid encourages this kind of niche expertise development as a legitimate path toward sustained betting performance.
Team news and injury information represent another critical dimension of pre-match research. The absence of a key goalkeeper, a central defensive partnership disrupted by suspension, or a creative midfielder managing a minor injury can all shift the expected outcome of a match in ways that odds may not immediately reflect, particularly in the hours immediately following team announcement. Betzoid advises bettors to monitor team news actively and understand how specific absences affect tactical setups and team dynamics, rather than simply noting that a player is unavailable without considering the downstream implications.
Psychological and motivational factors, often underweighted in purely statistical models, also feature in Betzoid’s analytical framework. Concepts such as the “dead rubber” effect — where teams with nothing to play for in a final fixture often underperform relative to expectations — or the tendency for newly promoted teams to overperform early in a season before opponents adjust to their style, represent the kind of contextual intelligence that distinguishes experienced bettors from purely data-driven approaches. Betzoid integrates these human elements into its strategic content, advocating for a holistic analytical methodology that combines quantitative rigor with qualitative judgment.
Bankroll Management, Discipline, and the Long-Term Mindset
Perhaps the most underappreciated dimension of football betting strategy is the psychological and organizational discipline required to sustain a structured approach over time. Betzoid addresses this dimension with the same seriousness it applies to technical strategy, recognizing that even the most analytically sophisticated bettor will fail without adequate bankroll management and emotional resilience.
Bankroll management begins with the fundamental principle of treating betting as a long-term probabilistic exercise rather than a series of isolated events. A bettor who views each wager independently, without reference to their overall position and the statistical variance inherent in betting outcomes, is vulnerable to the emotional volatility that drives poor decision-making. Betzoid advocates for a structured unit system, where each bet represents a consistent percentage of the total bankroll — typically between one and five percent depending on confidence level and edge assessment — allowing bettors to survive inevitable losing runs without catastrophic capital depletion.
Record-keeping is another practice that Betzoid emphasizes as essential rather than optional. Maintaining detailed records of every bet placed — including the market, odds, stake, outcome, and the reasoning behind the selection — allows bettors to identify patterns in their performance over time. Are certain markets consistently profitable while others drain the bankroll? Does performance vary by league, day of the week, or bet type? Without systematic record-keeping, these patterns remain invisible, and bettors cannot make evidence-based adjustments to their strategy.
The concept of line shopping — comparing odds across multiple bookmakers to consistently secure the best available price on each selection — is presented by Betzoid as a non-negotiable practice for serious bettors. The difference between obtaining 2.10 and 2.20 on a selection may appear trivial in isolation, but across hundreds of bets, consistently securing superior odds has a compounding positive effect on long-term returns. Betzoid contextualizes this within the broader principle that marginal gains, accumulated systematically over time, are the mechanism through which disciplined bettors generate sustainable performance.
Responsible gambling practices are woven throughout Betzoid’s educational content, reflecting an understanding that betting carries genuine risks of financial and psychological harm. The platform consistently frames betting as an activity requiring deliberate limits, honest self-assessment, and the willingness to step back when emotional states compromise rational decision-making. This responsible framing distinguishes Betzoid’s educational approach from resources that treat betting purely as an optimization problem without acknowledging the human dimensions of risk and loss.
Conclusion
Betzoid’s approach to covering football betting fundamentals reflects a genuine commitment to bettor education rather than superficial content designed merely to attract traffic. By addressing the full spectrum of strategic knowledge — from odds literacy and market understanding through advanced analytics, staking methodology, and psychological discipline — the platform provides a coherent educational framework that serves bettors at multiple stages of their development. Football betting will never be a guaranteed path to profit, but the structured, analytical approach that Betzoid advocates gives bettors the tools to engage with markets intelligently, manage risk responsibly, and develop the kind of long-term perspective that separates informed wagering from impulsive gambling. For anyone serious about improving their understanding of football betting, the depth and rigor of Betzoid’s educational content represents a genuinely valuable resource.
ICN in brief 2023/24
Check the 2023/24 ICN projects and get involved.
More detailed information and additional projects can be found in the ICN Working Group work plans available on the Working Group subpages along with the relevant contact information.
2024 ICN Advocacy Workshop

The ICN Advocacy Workshop will be hosted by the Competition Authority of Kenya in Nairobi from 22-23 February 2024.
The website is online, please click on the e-shot below.
How Casino Payout Rates Are Calculated and Verified, a Casimatic Overview
Understanding how casinos report their payout rates requires more than accepting a percentage figure at face value. Return to Player (RTP) statistics are among the most cited numbers in the gambling industry, yet the methodology behind them is frequently misunderstood by players and occasionally obscured by operators. A payout rate expressed as 96% does not mean a player will receive 96 cents back for every dollar wagered during a single session — it describes a theoretical long-run average calculated across millions of game rounds. The distinction matters enormously for anyone trying to evaluate the genuine value of a casino’s offering.
The Mathematics Behind RTP Calculations
Return to Player percentages originate at the game development stage, not at the casino level. Software providers such as NetEnt, Microgaming, Playtech, and Evolution Gaming program the mathematical models that determine how a game pays out over an extended sequence of play. For slot machines, RTP is derived from the game’s probability distribution — every symbol combination, its frequency of appearance, and its associated payout value are factored into a weighted formula. The sum of all possible outcomes multiplied by their respective probabilities, divided by the total amount wagered per spin, produces the theoretical RTP figure.
For table games, the calculation is more straightforward because the rules are fixed and the probability space is finite. European Roulette, for instance, has a house edge of 2.7%, which translates to an RTP of 97.3%. This figure is mathematically provable because the wheel contains 37 pockets and the standard single-number bet pays 35 to 1. Blackjack RTP can exceed 99.5% under optimal basic strategy, though it varies depending on the specific rule set — number of decks, dealer standing rules on soft 17, and availability of surrender all affect the final figure. These calculations have been standardized in academic literature since the mid-twentieth century and are not subject to operator manipulation at the software level.
Volatility, sometimes called variance, is a separate metric that interacts with RTP in ways players frequently conflate. A high-volatility slot may carry an RTP of 96.5% but deliver that return through infrequent large wins rather than consistent small payouts. Two games with identical RTPs can produce radically different player experiences depending on their hit frequency and maximum win potential. Game developers typically publish volatility classifications alongside RTP figures in their technical documentation, though casinos do not always surface this information prominently.
Independent Testing and Regulatory Verification
The credibility of any published RTP figure depends entirely on the verification process behind it. Regulatory bodies in major licensing jurisdictions require that games be tested by accredited independent laboratories before they are approved for real-money play. The most recognized testing organizations include eCOGRA (established in 2003 and headquartered in London), GLI (Gaming Laboratories International, founded in 1989 in the United States), BMM Testlabs, and iTech Labs. These organizations receive the game’s source code and mathematical model from the developer, run extensive simulation cycles — typically in the range of one billion to ten billion rounds — and verify that the observed output matches the theoretical RTP within an acceptable statistical tolerance.
In the United Kingdom, the Gambling Commission requires all licensed operators to publish game RTPs and mandates that the actual return over a defined period does not deviate from the certified figure by more than a specified margin. The Malta Gaming Authority, one of the most widely recognized offshore licensing bodies, enforces similar requirements under its Player Protection Directive. Gibraltar’s Regulatory Authority and the Isle of Man Gambling Supervision Commission apply comparable standards. The practical consequence is that a casino operating under a reputable license cannot simply adjust a game’s payout rate without triggering a compliance breach that would jeopardize its license.
Actual RTP monitoring occurs at two levels. First, the game itself contains a certified mathematical engine that cannot be altered by the casino operator — the software runs on the provider’s servers in most contemporary arrangements, particularly under the remote gaming server model that became dominant after 2010. Second, regulators and independent auditors conduct periodic reviews of actual payout data reported by operators. eCOGRA, for example, publishes monthly payout reports for casinos that subscribe to its certification program, listing the aggregate RTP across all games for that period. These figures represent real player outcomes rather than theoretical models and typically cluster within one to two percentage points of the certified theoretical values when sample sizes are large enough.
How Operators Influence Effective Payout Rates
While operators cannot alter the certified RTP of individual games, they exercise meaningful influence over a player’s effective return through game selection and promotional structures. Casinos curate their game libraries and can choose to offer versions of slots with different RTP configurations — many providers release the same title in multiple variants with RTPs ranging from 94% to 97%, allowing operators to select the version that suits their margin targets. This practice is legal under most licensing regimes as long as the published RTP matches the configured version, but it means that the same game title may pay differently across different platforms.
Bonus structures represent another layer of complexity. A welcome bonus with a 40x wagering requirement attached to a 100% match effectively dilutes the player’s theoretical return, because a significant portion of the bonus funds must be cycled through games before withdrawal eligibility is reached. The interaction between wagering requirements, game contribution percentages, and time limits creates an effective RTP for the bonus itself that is often substantially below the headline game RTP. Resources like http://casimatic.org/best-payout-casinos/ compile comparative data on these structures, which helps players assess the actual value of promotional offers rather than relying solely on the advertised match percentage.
Progressive jackpot games introduce additional nuance. A portion of each wager on a progressive slot feeds the jackpot pool, which means the base game RTP — the return excluding jackpot contributions — is lower than the total certified RTP. The full theoretical return is only achievable if the jackpot is eventually won, and for any individual player the probability of hitting a progressive jackpot worth millions from a modest session is negligibly small. Developers are required by most regulators to disclose both the base game RTP and the total RTP inclusive of jackpot contributions, but these figures are not always displayed with equal prominence on casino platforms.
Casimatic’s Methodology for Evaluating Payout Data
Analytical platforms that aggregate and present payout information face the challenge of reconciling theoretical RTPs published by developers with the more variable actual return figures reported by operators. Casimatic approaches this by cross-referencing certified RTP documentation from testing laboratories with the game configurations deployed by specific casinos, supplemented where available by published audit reports from eCOGRA and comparable bodies. This multi-source approach is necessary because a single theoretical RTP figure, without context about the specific game version deployed, the bonus conditions in effect, and the licensing jurisdiction’s audit requirements, provides an incomplete picture of what a player can realistically expect.
The process of evaluating payout rates also requires accounting for the distinction between overall casino RTP and game-specific RTP. An operator’s aggregate payout percentage — the total amount returned to players divided by total wagers across all games — reflects the composition of its game library as much as the individual game configurations. A casino that attracts a high volume of blackjack play will naturally report a higher aggregate RTP than one where traffic concentrates on low-volatility slots, even if neither operator has altered any individual game’s certified configuration. Casimatic’s analytical framework attempts to normalize for this effect by presenting game-category breakdowns rather than a single aggregate figure that can obscure meaningful variation.
Regulatory developments in the early 2020s have pushed toward greater transparency in this area. The United Kingdom Gambling Commission’s 2021 review of online slot regulations introduced restrictions on autoplay features, spin speeds, and certain bonus mechanics, indirectly affecting how RTPs are experienced in practice. Sweden’s Spelinspektionen has similarly tightened requirements around bonus offer transparency since the reregulation of the Swedish market in January 2019. These regulatory shifts mean that the landscape for payout verification is not static — methodologies that were adequate five years ago may no longer capture the full complexity of how modern online casino products are structured and experienced.
Payout rates are ultimately a statistical abstraction that becomes meaningful only when examined in conjunction with game variance, bonus conditions, licensing jurisdiction, and the specific game version deployed by an operator. The certified RTP from an independent laboratory provides a reliable baseline, but the gap between that baseline and a player’s actual experience in any given session can be substantial. Rigorous verification frameworks — combining regulatory oversight, independent auditing, and comparative analysis from platforms like Casimatic — represent the most reliable mechanism available for translating theoretical percentages into actionable information for players navigating an increasingly complex market.







